Strategy is Dead. Long Live Strategy.

10 considerations to optimise strategy in the turmoil of today’s business world.

Business has had to live with VUCA for some time. And it is here to stay.

Our fast-paced, globally connected world creates volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity. As a result, leaders increasingly question the value of business strategy. When circumstances change overnight, shouldn’t they focus on operations, continuous improvement, employee development and adaptability instead? Is strategy becoming irrelevant?

Businesses operate continuously, regardless of monthly or annual reporting cycles. Therefore, the process of running an organisation matters more than fixed planning periods. Former Microsoft strategy head Charlie Songhurst,  gives this metaphor:

“If you survive long enough, maybe greatness eventually becomes you. [So] what’s underestimated, is if you want to live forever, don’t start thinking about studying centenarians, instead, work out how to not die due to drunk driving or smoking twenty cigarettes a day.”

Perhaps a great strategy is simply this: Do good work. Repeat. Keep repeating.

Strategy by doing

The debate about strategy is not new. In the 1970s, Canadian academic Henry Mintzberg challenged traditional management thinking in his book The Nature of Managerial Work. He introduced emergent strategy, which develops as circumstances change, rather than following a detailed upfront plan.

Decades later, the LEGO turnaround reinforced this approach. In 2003, LEGO faced a $200 million loss, a 26% sales decline and $800 million in debt. New CEO Jørgen Knudstorp abandoned the company’s innovation-heavy strategy and refocused on core products, operations, customer loyalty and profitability.

By 2005, sales had increased by 12%, returning LEGO to profitability. Since then, the company has achieved sustained growth. Knudstorp demonstrated the power of strategy through action, echoing business leader Jack Welch’s philosophy:

“in real life, strategy is actually very straightforward. You pick a general direction and implement like hell.”

What about ideation and innovation?

Are you an action-oriented leader? While action matters, it does not always guarantee results. As management thinker Peter Drucker warned, “There is nothing so useless as doing efficiently that which should not be done at all.”

However, numerous case studies highlight the importance of strategic planning. Airbnb is one of many interesting illustrations.

Since launching in 2008, the company has balanced affordability, global connectivity, the sharing economy and technology. Yet changing regulations, customer trust, growing competition and the pandemic have forced Airbnb to adapt its strategy.

As a digital business, Airbnb must continually anticipate emerging challenges and competitive threats. Its success combines disruptive thinking, careful analysis and innovative ideas.

Ultimately, Airbnb demonstrates why innovation and adaptable business strategies remain essential for future-focused organisations.

Logical realities

Despite differing views on strategy, execution requires direction. Even a basic understanding of what a business wants to achieve represents a form of strategy.

For many organisations, financial performance drives decision-making. However, leaders must first define their goals and determine how to achieve them. Without clear direction, even ambitious targets lack purpose.

Most organisations need a strategy that suits their circumstances. LEGO succeeded by simplifying its approach, while Airbnb embraced complex technological, social and consumer trends.

Therefore, the question is not whether strategy is dead, but whether traditional approaches remain effective. Strategy remains essential, but outdated thinking can limit organisational success.

Strategy shortcomings

To understand why strategies fail, consider these five common challenges:

  1. Lack of focus. “You can’t be world-class in 97 different things,” said former Ford CEO Alan Mulally. Effective strategies require clear priorities and difficult choices.

  2. Internal conflicts. Office politics, competing interests and resistance to change can undermine strategy. Leaders must remain open-minded and prioritise organisational goals over personal agendas.

  3. Poor accountability. Unclear responsibilities, excessive input and limited involvement in execution weaken strategies. As implementation consultant Jeroen de Flander emphasises, strategists must take responsibility for execution.

  4. Inflexibility. Markets and circumstances constantly change. Therefore, organisations need adaptable strategies rather than relying on fixed assumptions.

  5. Unrealistic expectations. Even flexible strategies can fail without sufficient resources, realistic budgets, market understanding and adequate implementation time.

Strategy tips

To develop an effective business strategy, consider these five principles:

  1. Review your goals. “A goal without a plan is just a wish,” said writer and aviator Antoine de Saint-Exupéry. Clearly define and assess your objectives instead of simply repeating last year’s goals. This helps establish a focused strategic direction.

  2. Distinguish strategy from planning. As strategy expert Roger Martin points out, strategy involves making choices about where and how to compete successfully. It focuses on customers, competitive advantage and future opportunities. In contrast, plans outline internal activities and resources. Organisations can control their plans but can only influence strategic outcomes.

  3. Encourage collaboration. Involve employees across departments and seniority levels in strategy development. Diverse perspectives from analysts, specialists and frontline employees can reveal valuable insights, strengthen engagement and improve execution.

  4. Challenge biases. Personal assumptions can weaken strategic decisions, especially in uncertain environments. Therefore, use current data and analytics rather than relying solely on past experiences or recent trends. Balance short-term developments with long-term market patterns.

  5. Embrace uncertainty. No strategy can predict every future challenge. Instead, develop flexible approaches for different scenarios and remain agile enough to adjust execution as circumstances change.

Culture closes execution gaps

A successful strategy depends on effective execution. However, closing the gap between planning and action requires understanding employees’ perspectives.

 

When employees connect strategy to the organisation’s purpose, they are more likely to support it. Furthermore, recognising that strategies must evolve helps them embrace change and adapt quickly.

 

Involving employees in strategy development also strengthens engagement, encourages curiosity and creates a sense of ownership.

 

Ultimately, organisational culture shapes how employees execute strategy. As Peter Drucker famously said, “Culture eats strategy for breakfast.” This highlights the importance of aligning strategy, culture and execution.

Perseverant, pervasive strategy

Strategy remains essential to business success. However, leaders must rethink how they develop, communicate and execute it. Effective strategies require clear objectives, employee involvement and a supportive organisational culture.

 

If your organisation struggles with strategy, review the processes, people and practical steps that shape its execution.

 

Ready to strengthen your organisation’s strategic capabilities? DigitalCampus offers online short courses, including Strategic Thinking Skills Using Behavioural Science and Neurostrategy.

 

Contact us to learn more, or visit our website to develop your team’s strategic skills.

 

DigitalCampus is part of the LRMG group, specialists in igniting the performance of people.  

Written By:

Kevin Williams

Managing Executive for DigitalCampus • SRE

DigitalCampus

In partnership with Dave Gorin